Top

Why Celebs Avoid Taking a Stand on Controversial Subjects

The silence of Bollywood’s biggest stars on Sonam Wangchuk’s hunger strike has drawn sharp criticism, especially as the movement has found support among the country’s youth. But before dismissing celebrities as indifferent/opportunistic, it is worth asking whether speaking out is a luxury they can afford. In today’s deeply polarised climate, voicing an opinion on politically sensitive issues can have serious consequences for a star’s career

As the engineer-turned-activist Sonam Wangchuk sat on an indefinite fast demanding accountability over alleged irregularities in competitive examinations and seeking the resignation of Union Education Minister Dharmendra Pradhan, only a handful of film personalities, including Hrithik Roshan, Sonakshi Sinha, Dia Mirza, Zoya Akhtar, prakash Raj, Shabana Azmi and Kiran Rao, publicly expressed support. Most of Hindi cinema’s biggest stars remained conspicuously silent.

Ironically, the loudest conversation was not about Wangchuk’s campaign but about 3 Idiots. Aamir Khan publicly clarified that his character in Rajkumar Hirani’s 2009 blockbuster was not based on Wangchuk and that he had neither known nor met the activist during the making of the film. The clarification triggered a social media storm after users resurfaced old interviews in which Wangchuk recalled Aamir visiting his school, along with a 2008 video showing the actor attending one of his talks. Hirani, too, reiterated that the film’s protagonist was inspired by the life of a film school student rather than Wangchuk.

Whether 3 Idiots was inspired by Wangchuk is, ultimately, a footnote. The larger question is why an issue as fundamental as the integrity of India’s examination system failed to evoke a stronger response from an industry that has often celebrated education, equality and social change on screen.

Filmmaker Amit Rai, director of Oh My God 2, believes the silence reflects a wider erosion of social consciousness. “We are all complicit. There has been such a decline in empathy and compassion. Today, everything is weighed in terms of profit and loss and what benefits us personally. This isn’t new. Many in the industry don’t even speak up when one of their own is suffering. During the success of Dhurandhar, hardly anyone celebrated because jealousy and insecurity often take over. So do you really think people will speak up on an issue like this, especially when they have nothing to gain? It is deeply troubling that we have become so insensitive to everything happening around us.”

Over the years, Bollywood’s biggest stars have adopted carefully calibrated public personas. Amitabh Bachchan has largely stayed away from polarising political debates. Akshay Kumar and Ajay Devgn have often projected their political leanings more through the films they choose than through public statements. Priyanka Chopra has balanced a liberal global image with a carefully crafted patriotic and pragmatic stance in India.

Deepika Padukone’s appearance at Delhi’s Jawaharlal Nehru University during the 2020 student protests invited political backlash, with many believing it affected the commercial prospects of Chhapaak. Since then, she has largely stayed away from socio-political issues.

Kangana Ranaut, now a Member of Parliament, has never shied away from commenting on political issues, particularly when her views align with the ruling establishment, as seen during the farmers’ protests. However, critics point out that she has been noticeably restrained whenever an issue could place her at odds with the party she represents.

Film writer and author Yasser Usman points to Aamir Khan’s experience in 2015, when his comments on rising intolerance in India sparked a massive backlash. “Regardless of one’s view of what he said, the reaction was substantial. Incidents like that inevitably influence how other celebrities assess the risks of speaking out.” He adds, “Remaining politically neutral — or at least publicly silent — has become a way for many stars to avoid alienating sections of their audience, business partners and even global streaming platforms that prefer to stay away from controversy.”

Stars & Silence

Over the years, Bollywood’s biggest stars have adopted carefully calibrated public personas. Amitabh Bachchan, Deepika Padukone, Akshay Kumar, Ajay Devgn, Priyanka Chopra, Kangana Ranaut have stayed away from polarising political debates.

( Source : Deccan Chronicle )
Next Story