Teaching on Thin Ice!
As student protests and stress rise, teachers too find themselves walking a legal tightrope — caught between protecting students and fearing the consequences of doing their jobs

Sudheendra Kulkarni, an alumnus of IIT Bombay, B-Tech- Civil Eng-ineering, Batch of 1975-1980 says, “Academic institutions work best when they are free of fear.” He explains that students need an atmosphere that fosters trust, amiability and collaborative growth. Kulkarni points out that, with very few exceptions, IIT faculty teach and interact with students without caste or communal bias. Strict guidelines apply equally to teachers and students against bringing such biases into classrooms or anywhere on campus.
Wakode’s death, following an examination incident in which he was questioned by a professor over alleged use of a mobile phone, has triggered allegations, protests, an institutional inquiry and now a CBI probe.
Teaching Trouble
For teachers, the episode has opened up a larger concern. If enforcing exam rules or questioning a student over alleged misconduct can leave a teacher facing legal action, will teachers begin to think twice before simply doing their jobs?
Sudheendra quips, “The focus in any institution is entirely on academic excellence and cultivating creativity.” However, he cautions that if the “Sword of Damocles” of the SC/ST Act hangs over faculty, it could stifle the openness and fear-free mentorship students need. He adds that the lack of preliminary inquiry and difficulty in securing anticipatory bail under the act, can make the process itself feel like punishment, calling it “patently discriminatory” and “reverse casteism.”
Atmosphere of Stress
The concerns around teachers cannot be viewed in isolation. They come against a backdrop of mounting pressure on students as well. At IITs, IIMs, medical colleges and NLUs, students deal with fierce competition, heavy workloads, high expectations and constant performance pressure.
“We often reduce such conversations to academic pressure, but I think that is far too simplistic.” says Rishabh Shah, Founder, India’s International Movement to Unite Nations (I.I.M.U.N) from Mumbai. He says many students face a major psychological shift when they enter institutions like the IITs. Once the brightest in their school or town, they suddenly find themselves among equally high achievers—facing average grades, rejection, loneliness and, for some, failure for the first time.
Rishabh says counselling alone isn’t enough. Students need stronger support systems, smaller mentor groups, regular counsellor access, trained hostel wardens and peer support. In terms of teachers’ well-being, Rishabh adds, “A teacher must be able to enforce discipline, question academic misconduct, fail a student where academically justified, or report cheating without constantly wondering whether doing his job will result in criminal intimidation or personal destruction.”
Guilty First, Innocent Later
Adv. Prachi Pratap, an Advocate & Professor of Criminal Law explains that legal remedies are available to educators who believe they have been falsely accused or publicly defamed. “A teacher or professor can seek anticipatory bail, approach the High Court to quash a baseless FIR, and challenge a mechanical or prolonged suspension,” she says. The legal remedies available would ultimately depend on the facts and circumstances of each case.
If the teacher is eventually cleared of the charges, Adv Prachi explains that further remedies may include proceedings for a false charge, a claim for malicious prosecution, and civil or criminal defamation. “The SC has recognised reputation as part of the Right to Life, and courts can award compensation in cases of groundless arrest,” she says. However, legal remedies may not fully undo the damage already caused to a teacher’s career, family or standing in the community.
Institutional Reboot
Perhaps, what's needed is an institutional reboot, one that protects students from moments of vulnerability while also giving teachers a fair, transparent and safe framework to do their jobs. Rajendra Shinde, Former Principal of St. Xavier’s College, Mumbai says, “Nowadays, CCTV cameras are mandatory in every classroom, that could be the best solution for starters.” He also calls for regular awareness sessions for students, teachers and parents on conduct, boundaries and institutional rules, beginning in high school rather than as one-off exercises. Trust between teachers and students, he says, still matters.But teachers have little formal protection. “There is practically nothing in writing” to support them, he says, leaving many to rely on teachers’ unions for legal help. Any financial support from institutions often depends on individual managements.
The Way Ahead
The way ahead lies in creating safer campuses for both students and teachers. Institutions need clear protocols for handling complaints, timely and fair inquiries, accessible counselling and legal support, and regular conversations on boundaries, mental health and grievance redressal. Teachers, too, need the freedom to teach, guide and discipline without fear. Accountability must protect, not paralyse; safeguards must build trust, not fear!
Worrisome Numbers
65% of surveyed higher-education institutions reported no access to mental-health service provided (SC-appointed National Task Force, 2026)
At IIT Madras, 3% of newly admitted students were in the “worry zone” and 32% in the “focus zone” (2024 Well-being Survey)
At IIT Bombay- A survey of 600 students found that 245 felt they need professional mental-health support but did not seek it (Insight, IIT Bombay Student Media Body, 2025)
A study of 8,542 college students across 30 universities in 9 states found 33.6% reported moderate-to-severe depressive symptoms and 23.2% moderate-to-severe anxiety symptoms (Indian Journal of Psychological Medicine, 2024)
Academic institutions work best when they are free of fear.”
Sudheendra Kulkarni, alumnus of IIT Bombay
Many students undergo a profound psychological transition when they enter institutions like the IITs.”
Rishabh Shah, Founder, I.I.M.U.N
Now a days, CCTV cameras are mandatory y in every classroom, that could be the best solution for starters.”
Rajendra Shinde, Former Principal, St. Xavier’s College, Mumbai

