Top

HC Division Bench Suspends Single Judge Order Directing HYDRAA Chief Ranganath’s Removal

It adjourned the matter to November 3 for further hearing.

Hyderabad: A division bench of the Telangana High Court suspended the order of a single judge directing the state government to relieve HYDRAA commissioner A.V. Ranganath from the post over alleged repeated wilful disobedience of court orders in connection with a 40-acre land parcel at Lothkunta in Secunderabad. The bench also directed Ranganath and HYDRAA officials to not to enter or interfere with the disputed property until further orders.

The court, however, grilled Ranganath and HYDRAA for entering and acting upon land that was already the subject of litigation, court orders, surveys not being conducted or demarcated and contempt proceedings.

In regarding to the land at Lothkunta, the bench observed that HYDRAA proceeding with fencing of the property without first establishing whether the land in Survey No.s 1 and 2 in Lothkunta was the same as, or distinct from, the land covered by GLR 243 amounted to an approach lacking in the caution expected from officials entrusted with protecting government property.

The division bench comprising Justice P. Sam Koshy and Justice Nandikonda Narsing Rao was hearing an appeal filed by Ranganath challenging the single judge’s contempt order passed on a petition by Shanta Sriram Constructions Private Limited in regarding the Lothkunta land.

The bench granted an interim stay on the single judge’s direction that Ranganath be relieved from the post, and made it clear that the commissioner and HYDRAA personnel should stay away from the disputed site. It adjourned the matter to November 3 for further hearing.

Senior counsel Rajeev Shakdher, appearing for Ranganath, argued that the commissioner had not deliberately violated any judicial order and had visited the site pursuant to official directions to protect government land. Whether any violation had occurred and, if so, whether it was inadvertent or wilful, required detailed examination, he submitted.

Shakdher contended that Ranganath was not given adequate opportunity before the single judge to explain his position. His request for time to file an additional counter-affidavit was not granted, he said.

Senior counsel questioned the severity of the punishment imposed in the contempt proceedings, arguing that directing the government to relieve the commissioner went beyond the permissible scope of contempt jurisdiction. Citing several Supreme Court judgments, he submitted that a single judge could not impose a punishment outside the parameters prescribed under the law governing contempt.

Counsel appearing for Shanta Sriram Constructions expressed lack of confidence in the state machinery and suggested that, if necessary, the survey of the disputed property be entrusted to an independent agency such as the Survey of India.

During the hearing, the Bench repeatedly questioned the manner in which HYDRAA proceeded with the property despite the existence of litigation and earlier judicial proceedings. “You are the person responsible for protecting government land. At the same time, you are also the first person who must respect court orders,” the bench observed, stressing that HYDRAA officials were required to exercise greater caution whenever they were aware of a dispute.

The judges questioned whether it was appropriate for an entire government machinery to be mobilised merely on the request of another department without first verifying the survey number, identity and status of the property. The bench pointed out that before fencing the site, officials ought to have established whether the disputed actually formed part of the government land or constituted a different parcel. They should also have verified whether any litigation was pending over the property, the stage of such proceedings and whether any orders had already been passed by courts.

“Protecting government land is certainly HYDRAA’s responsibility, but the government also has a responsibility to protect the rights of private individuals,” the bench observed.



( Source : Deccan Chronicle )
Next Story