The Rational Revolutionary: Nehru Through the Eyes of Bhagat Singh and Bose

Bhagat Singh on Nehru and Bose

In the July 1928 issue of Kirti magazine, Bhagat Singh wrote in "Different Thoughts of New Leaders":

“Jawaharlal and Subhas Babu are patriots highly committed to Indian independence.”

He admired Bose’s fervour but noted:

“Subhas Babu’s speech, full of fanciful words, appeals to sentiments but cannot arouse revolutionary fervor.”

On Nehru, he praised:

“Pandit Nehru, highly educated, emphasises reason and reform in politics, religion, society, and economy.”

He concluded:

“Young revolutionaries must follow Nehru’s path for a successful movement.”

Bose’s Letter to Nehru

In 1936, Subhas Chandra Bose wrote to Nehru from Darjeeling:

June 30, 1936

My dear Jawahar,

I was glad to receive your letter of June 22. I’m worried about your health due to overwork. I hope you rest. Regarding Ranjit, I’m relieved doctors suspect nothing serious. I’m comfortable here despite minor ailments. If possible, send books like *Historical Geography of Europe* by Gordon East or others from my list. Address them c/o Superintendent of Police, Darjeeling.

With love,

Subhas

This letter reflects Bose’s broad intellectual interests and his bond with Nehru.

Conclusion

Bhagat Singh saw Nehru as a rationalist leader, while Bose admired him as an intellectual peer. Their exchanges highlight the ideological pluralism of India’s freedom struggle. In an age of polarization, their writings remind us that disagreement doesn’t mean division, and civil discourse is vital for democracy. Nehru’s legacy, respected by Singh and Bose, endures for its intellectual power.

References: A Bunch of Old Letters, Kirti Magazine (July 1928), Nehru Memorial Museum & Library Archives.