Modi govt's plan to amend Enemy Property Act may not pass Rajya Sabha hurdle

New Delhi: The Modi government's attempt to amend the 48-year-old Enemy Property Act has faced a stumbling block and is unlikely to clear the Rajya Sabha hurdle with four political parties opposing the move saying original law was balanced and fresh changes violate the basic principle of natural justice.

Congress, JD-U, CPI and Samajwadi Party said the proposed changes would result in punishing lakhs of Indian citizens and have no effect on any 'Enemy Government'.

The representatives of the four parties -- KC Tyagi (JD-U), K Rahman Khan, P L Punia and Husain Dalwai (all Congress), D Raja (CPI) and Javed Ali Khan (SP) -- gave their dissent notes in the Select Committee report on amendments to the Enemy Property Act, 1968, tabled in Rajya Sabha on Friday.

"The provisions of the present Bill, 2016 are contrary to the aforesaid principles and if allowed to be inserted in the Act, 1968, not only the entire balance will be disturbed but also the same would not sustain in the courts of law. Thus, we are submitting this dissent note with the request that the same may kindly be treated and circulated as part and parcel of the report of this committee," the dissent note said.

The MPs said that in their considered view, the provisions of the present bill violates the very basic Principle of Natural Justice, Human Rights and settled principles of law.

Furthermore, it adversely affects and results in punishing lakhs of Indian citizens and will have no effect on any enemy government.

In April, the government had promulgated an ordinance to amend the Enemy Property Act to guard against claims of succession or transfer of properties left by people who migrated mostly to Pakistan after the wars.

Since NDA government does not enjoy majority in the Rajya Sabha, the proposed amendment bill is unlikely to pass the Upper House hurdle as the four parties opposed the move.

The Centre had designated some properties belonging to nationals of Pakistan as "enemy properties" during the 1962, 1965 and 1971 conflicts. It vested these properties in the 'Custodian of Enemy Property for India', an office instituted under the central government.

The Enemy Property Act, 1968, regulates these enemy properties, and lists the powers of the custodian.

In the wake of the Indo-Pak wars of 1965 and 1971, there was migration of people from India to Pakistan. Under the Defence of India Rules framed under the Defence of India Act, the government took over the properties and companies of such persons who had taken Pakistani nationality.

The central government through the Custodian of Enemy Property for India is in possession of enemy properties spread across many states in the country. In addition, there are also movable properties categorised as enemy properties.

After the 1965 war, India and Pakistan signed the Tashkent Declaration which included a clause saying that the two countries would discuss the return of the property and assets taken over by either side in connection with the conflict.