Top

Book Excerpt | The Chip Age: How Semiconductors Became the World’s Most Powerful Resource

Chip gap between nations is increasing, and it is increasing global inequality with it



We are back into another chip shortage – this time, it is hard to access CPU, GPU, and memory chips. What is not getting as much attention is that this shortage is affecting different nations differently. It is becoming hard for most nations on earth – barring a few rich countries- to access chips, especially advanced chips. AI has exacerbated this problem by pushing demands to a point where a small number of nations – US, China, and some countries in Europe - consume almost all AI chips. Only some are left for others.
Just as access to advanced chips has created significant technological and strategic advantages, a lack of access is creating a "chip gap" between nations. This gap will impact equality, widen economic disparities, and exacerbate geopolitical tensions. The concentration of advanced semiconductor manufacturing in a handful of countries gives them immense technological and economic power, while nations without this capability risk being left behind.
Economic inequality will increase due to a widening of the digital divide. Nations that lack access to advanced chips will fall behind in AI, high-performance computing, and telecommunications, and miss out on the direct and indirect economic value and the productivity and innovation advantages they create. We are already seeing the US and, to a lesser extent, China dominate the world of AI and derive most of the economic and innovation benefits. This is in no small part due to their access to the most advanced AI chips. The economic and technological gap between these nations and the rest of the world will only grow if the chip gap remains.
Second, if AI thrives elsewhere, it will draw away skilled workers (brain drain), further exacerbating the disadvantages against chip-rich countries. Any low-cost labor advantage of developing nations will also disappear due to increased and better automation elsewhere.
A lack of chip access will also stymie the growth of key industries such as consumer electronics, automotive manufacturing, and data centers that need advanced chips. These industries, and others, will also become less competitive in developing nations due to greater and better use of automation in chip-rich nations.
Wealthier nations will also invest more in capital-intensive chip infrastructure and innovation, creating a self-reinforcing advantage. Overall, this will create a low-income and low quality-of- life trap for developing nations, while wealthier nations accrue a disproportionate and increasing share of global wealth and innovation.
Geopolitical divides will also increase. A nation’s access to chips and its participation in chip supply chains are threatened when other nations prioritize their domestic chip self-sufficiency.
The US CHIPS and Science Act and the EU Chips Act, for example, have created a major economic risk for several nations that participate in today’s complex chip supply chains.
Chip nationalism by wealthy nations also disrupts existing supply chains that are optimized for cost and efficiency. These disruptions increase chip costs and insecurity and harm developing nations disproportionately. The chip gap may also be weaponized by chip-rich nations using export controls, exacerbating tensions, and using strategic dependence as leverage. A lack of access to advanced chips will also directly degrade defense capabilities, limiting geopolitical maneuvers.
So, what should the chip-rich nations do? They should work actively on improving access to chips for other nations to reduce extreme economic inequality. There are several incentives for them to do so: to preserve their ability to sell goods and services to vast populations that reside in chip-poor countries, to preserve their ability to form environmental, health, and supply chain partnerships with these nations, and to mitigate the social and political tensions in these nations that extreme inequality creates, which may lead to conflicts, extremism, and mass migration that may also affect the chip-rich countries.
To improve access, chip-rich nations should provide lower- and middle-income countries with credits and training for cloud-based access to chips. Instead of exporting chips to individual nations, chip-rich nations should support regional compute hubs that allow pooling of chip resources to mitigate costs. Subsidized and preferential access to chips should be provided to countries that best demonstrate the ability to make use of them for social and economic welfare.
And what should the chip-poor nations do? They should leverage geopolitical tensions to their advantage and negotiate chip access in exchange for alignment of their tech ecosystems with their chip partners. They should also be willing to trade for chip access in exchange for goods and services or providing access to local markets. They should reduce their chip demands by pooling resources with their allies (e.g., to build shared, large data centers) and embracing small and efficient machine learning models. They should strengthen their negotiation position by bargaining collectively with their allies. They should reduce their overall chip costs and security by participating downstream in the chip supply chain. To prevent brain drain, they should invest heavily in application areas where they can compete (e.g., edge AI). They should invest in education and workforce development accordingly.
It is often said that chips are the new oil. Every country needs oil, irrespective of whether it can produce it or afford it. The world has come up with a system that allows everyone to access it.
The same needs to be done for chips now.


Next Story