Business Autos 09 Feb 2019 New Maruti Wagon R 2 ...

New Maruti Wagon R 2019 vs Hyundai Grand i10: Clash of segments

CARDEKHO
Published Feb 9, 2019, 12:54 pm IST
Updated Feb 9, 2019, 12:54 pm IST
Can similarly priced variants of the new Wagon R prove their worth against the Grand i10’s?
et’s see if the Maruti offers better value (based on the features on offer) when it comes to similarly priced variants.
 et’s see if the Maruti offers better value (based on the features on offer) when it comes to similarly priced variants.

Launched at Rs 4.19 lakh (ex-showroom Delhi), the 2019 Maruti Wagon R rivals the likes of the Datsun GO, Hyundai Santro and the Tata Tiago. That said, some of its variants also go up against bigger hatchbacks like the Grand i10 and the KUV100. While we have already seen how the Wagon R fares against the Ignis, this time we have pitted it against the Grand i10. Let’s see if the Maruti offers better value (based on the features on offer) when it comes to similarly priced variants.

Before we dive into the detailed comparison, let’s take look at the major differences between the two hatchbacks.

 

Maruti Wagon R

Hyundai Grand i10

A compact hatchback: The Wagon R is a compact hatchback, which basically sits between entry-level hatchbacks (like Alto 800) and midsize hatchbacks (like Maruti Swift).

A midsize hatchback: A segment above the Wagon R, the Grand i10 sits between the Hyundai Santro and Elite i20.

Two petrol engines: Along with a 1.0-litre petrol engine, the new Wagon R also gets a 83PS/113Nm 1.2-litre four-cylinder petrol engine from the Ignis Both the engines are marted to a 5-speed MT and AMT.

Diesel fuel option: Unlike the Wagon R, the Grand i10 is available with both petrol and diesel engine options. While the petrol engine is a 1.2-litre unit, it gets a 1.2-litre 75PS/190Nm diesel engine options as well with a 5-speed MT.

AMT: The Wagon R gets a 5-speed AMT gearbox too. It can be had with both the engine options, but in V and Z variants only.

Torque Converter: The Grand i10 petrol, on the other hand, can be had with a 4-speed torque converter automatic gearbox as well. It is available in the Magna and Sportz variants only.

Rivals: Hyundai Santro, Datsun GO and Tata Tiago

Rivals: Maruti Ignis, KUV100, Maruti Swift, Ford Figo

Dimensions:

2019 Maruti Suzuki WagonR

 

2019 Maruti Wagon R

Hyundai Grand i10

Length

3655mm

3765mm

Width

1620mm

1660mm

Height

1675mm

1520mm

Wheelbase

2435mm

2425mm

  • The Grand i10 is longer and wider than the Wagon R.
  • Despite being from a segment below, the Wagon R has a longer wheelbase.

Engine:

 

2019 Maruti Wagon R

Hyundai Grand i10

Engine

1.0-litre/1.2-litre

1.2-litre

Power

68PS/83PS

83PS

Torque

90Nm/113Nm

113Nm

Transmission

5-speed MT/AMT

5-speed MT/4-speed AT

  • While the Wagon R is available with two petrol engine options, the Grand i10 gets only one petrol engine.
  • The Grand i10’s 1.2-litre unit makes 15PS/23Nm more than the Wagon R’s 1.0-litre unit, however, its power and torque figures are identical to the Maruti’s 1.2-litre unit.
  • Both the cars are offered with a manual transmission as well as an automatic gearbox. However, the Wagon R comes with an AMT, whereas the Grand i10 gets a torque converter unit.

Variants: We will be comparing similarly priced variants only, where price difference is ~ Rs 50,000.

Maruti Wagon R VXI(O) 1.2L vs Hyundai Grand i10 Era

Hyundai Grand i10

Maruti Wagon R VXI(O) 1.2L

Rs 4.95 lakh

Hyundai Grand i10 Era

Rs 5 lakh

Difference

+5,000 (Grand i10 is more expensive)

Common Features

Safety: Dual front airbags and ABS with EBD

Exterior: Body-coloured bumpers

Comfort: Power steering, manual AC, front power windows and adjustable ORVMs.

2019 Maruti Suzuki WagonR

What Maruti Wagon R VXI(O) 1.2L offers over Hyundai Grand i10 Era: Rear parking sensors, speed alert system, front seatbelt with pretensioner and load limiters, front seatbelt reminder, speed sensing door lock, central locking, roof antenna, front fog lamps, wheel caps, body-coloured door handles and ORVMs, keyless entry, 60:40 split rear seats, electrically adjustable ORVMs, manual day/night IRVM, tilt-adjustable steering, rear power windows, SmartPlay Dock 2-din music system with Bluetooth, Aux and USB and steering mounted controls.

What Hyundai Grand i10 Era offers over Maruti Wagon R VXI(O) 1.2L: Nothing

Verdict: Without a doubt, the Wagon R is our pick here. Despite being more affordable than the Grand i10, it packs a whole lot of important features for safety, comfort and entertainment.

Also Read: All-New Maruti Alto Likely To Be Based On Third-Gen Wagon R 2019

Maruti Wagon R ZXI vs Hyundai Grand i10 Magna

Hyundai Grand i10

Maruti Wagon R ZXI

Rs 5.22 lakh

Hyundai Grand i10 Magna

Rs 5.75 lakh

Difference

+53,000 (Grand i10 is more expensive)

Common Features (over previous variants):

Safety: Central locking and speed-sensing door lock.

Exterior: Body-coloured ORVMs and door handles, roof antenna and wheel covers.

Comfort: Day/night IRVM, keyless entry, rear power windows, steering-mounted controls, rear AC vents and electrically adjustable ORVMs.

Infotainment: 2-din music system with Bluetooth, Aux and USB support.

Hyundai Grand i10

What Maruti Wagon R ZXI offers over Hyundai Grand i10 Magna: Rear parking sensors, speed alert system, front seatbelt with pretensioner and load limiters, front seatbelt reminder, front fog lamps, turn indicators on ORVMs, tilt-adjustable steering, rear washer and wiper with defogger, a 7-inch touchscreen infotainment system with Apple CarPlay and Android Auto, electrically foldable ORVMs and front fog lamps.

What Hyundai Grand i10 Magna offers over Maruti Wagon R ZXI: Rear AC vents

Verdict: The Wagon R continues to be our pick simply because it is way better equipped than the Grand i10. The Hyundai does get rear AC vents, which the Wagon R misses out on, but it is a fair trade off considering the extra features the Wagon R has and the premium the Grand i10 commands.

Why Buy Wagon R?

Better Equipped: In all the variants we have compared, the Wagon R is clearly the better equipped car than the Grand i10 on all fronts. All this, while being more affordable.

More Versatile: The Wagon R comes with 60:40 split rear seats, which makes the hatchback more versatile. When not in use, the rear seats can be folded down to open up an enormous 710-litre boot.

Why Buy Grand i10:

Rear AC vents: If you are someone who will spend a majority of time in the back seat or travel with family most of the times, the rear AC vents on the Hyundai could be a useful feature.

A Bigger Car: The  Grand i10 is longer and wider than the Wagon R, so it will feel more premium and be comfortable on the inside too.

2019 Maruti Suzuki WagonR

Prices (ex-showroom Delhi)

Maruti WagonR

Hyundai Grand i10

   

LXI 1.0L: Rs 4.19 lakh/LXI(O) Rs 4.25 lakh

 
   

VXI 1.0L: Rs 4.69 lakh/VXI(O) Rs 4.75 lakh

 

VXI 1.2L: Rs 4.89 lakh/VXI(O) Rs 4.95 lakh

Era Rs 5 lakh

ZXI 1.2L: Rs 5.22 lakh

Magna Rs 5.75 lakh

 

Sportz Rs 6.14 lakh

 

Sportz Dual Tone Rs 6.39 lakh

 

Asta Rs 6.65 lakh

   

VXI 1.0L AGS: Rs 5.16 lakh/VXI(O) Rs 5.22 lakh

 

VXI 1.2L AGS: Rs 5.36 lakh/VXI(O) Rs 5,42 lakh

 

ZXI 1.2L AGS: Rs 5.69 lakh

 
 

Magna Auto 6.55 lakh

 

Sportz Auto Rs 7.08 lakh

Also Read: 2019 Maruti Wagon R vs Tata Tiago: Variants Comparison

Disclaimer: This article has not been edited by Deccan Chronicle and is taken from a syndicated feed. Photos: CarDekho.

...




ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT