Clash of segments: New WagonR 2019 vs Maruti Ignis - which car to buy?

CARDEKHO
Published Feb 2, 2019, 12:36 pm IST
Updated Feb 2, 2019, 12:36 pm IST
A tried and tested tallboy hatchback retailed through Arena dealerships or a quirky, millennial-centric Nexa offering.
 Maruti Wagon R 2019 improves upon a tried and tested formula that has worked wonders for Maruti.
  Maruti Wagon R 2019 improves upon a tried and tested formula that has worked wonders for Maruti.

Launched at prices ranging from Rs 4.19 lakh to Rs 5.69 lakh (ex-showroom New Delhi), the Maruti Wagon R 2019 improves upon a tried and tested formula that has worked wonders for Maruti. However, its prices overlap with the Maruti Ignis, which is a quirky offering, targeted more towards millennials. Also, while the former is retailed through Maruti's Arena dealership network, the latter is sold through the more premium Nexa chain of dealerships. In case, you are confused among the two, we have got your back. We have compared closely priced variants of the two to find out which one should you put your money on.

First, let us have a look at the basic differences between the new WagonR and the Ignis.

 

Maruti Suzuki WagonR

Maruti Suzuki Ignis

Powertrain: The WagonR is available with two petrol engines (1.0-litre and 1.2-litre), both of which can be had with a manual transmission as well as an AMT. There’s no diesel option though.

Powertrain: The Ignis is offered only with one petrol engine (1.2-litre), which can be had with both manual transmission and an AMT. Both the Ignis and WagonR get the same 1.2-litre petrol engine.

Sold from Arena showrooms: The WagonR is retailed from Maruti Suzuki Arena dealerships.

Sold from Nexa showrooms: The Ignis is retailed through Nexa showrooms and is positioned as a premium offering.

Direct Competition: The WagonR’s primary rivals in the market are the Hyundai Santro, Tata Tiago and Datsun GO.

Direct Competition: The Ignis’ competition in the market is the Hyundai Grand i10 and Mahindra KUV100.

Dimensions comparison

Measurements

Maruti Suzuki WagonR

Maruti Suzuki Ignis

Length

3655mm

3700mm

Width

1620mm

1690mm

Height

1675mm

1595mm

Wheelbase

2435mm

2435mm

Ground Clearance

NA

180mm

Boot Space

341 litres

260 litres

  • Both the new WagonR and the Ignis are based on the same Heartect A platform. Their wheelbase is also identical.

  • The Ignis is, however, longer and wider than the WagonR.

  • But the WagonR has a bigger boot - its boot volume is 81 litres more than that of the Ignis.

Engine comparison

Engine

WagonR 1.0-litre

WagonR 1.2-litre

Ignis 1.2-litre

Displacement

1.0-litre

1.2-litre

1.2-litre

Power

67PS

82PS

82PS

Torque

90Nm

113Nm

113Nm

Transmission

5-speed MT/AMT

5-speed MT/AMT

5-speed MT/AMT

Fuel Efficiency

22.5kmpl

21.5kmpl

20.89kmpl

  • Both the Ignis and WagonR share the same 1.2-litre petrol engine in the same state of tune. Both offer manual as well as automatic transmission options.

  • The WagonR is lighter than the Ignis. It is more fuel efficient as well, by 0.61kmpl.

  • The WagonR can also be had with a 1.0-litre engine, which is less powerful than the 1.2-litre unit. The WagonR 1.0 is more fuel efficient than the WagonR 1.2 by 1kmpl. This engine can also be had with both manual and automatic transmission options.

Now that we have differentiated the two based on basic differences, dimensions and engine specs, let’s have a look at the prices of different variants of the WagonR and Ignis. We will only be comparing variants that are priced within Rs 50,000 of each other. (Prices of all variants of both the cars are at the end of this story)

Maruti Suzuki WagonR Variant

Price

Maruti Suzuki Ignis Variant

Price

WagonR 1.0 VXi Opt.

Rs 4.75 lakh

Ignis 1.2 Sigma

Rs 4.67 lakh

WagonR 1.2 ZXi

Rs 5.22 lakh

Ignis 1.2 Delta

Rs 5.28 lakh

WagonR 1.2 ZXi AMT

Rs 5.69 lakh

Ignis 1.2 AMT Delta

Rs 5.83 lakh

All prices are (ex-showroom New Delhi)

Variants Comparison

WagonR 1.0 VXi (O) vs Ignis 1.2 Sigma

WagonR 1.0 VXi (O)

Ignis 1.2 Sigma

Price Difference

Rs 4.75 lakh

Rs 4.67 lakh

Rs 8,000 (WagonR is more expensive)

Common features: Tilt-adjustable steering, front power windows, uto-down driver window, dual airbags, seatbelt pre-tensioner & force limiters (driver and co-driver), ABS with EBD, speed sensing auto door locks, body coloured door handles, ORVMs and bumpers, driver seat belt reminder, 12V power outlet

What WagonR 1.0 VXi (O) has over Ignis 1.2 Sigma: Remote keyless entry, rear power windows, audio system with Bluetooth/USB/Aux connectivity, 2 speakers, rear parking sensors, electrically adjustable ORVM, passenger seatbelt reminder, Day/Night IRVM, rear seat 60:40 split

What Ignis 1.2 Sigma has over WagonR 1.0 VXi (O): ISOFIX child seat anchor points

Verdict: The mid-spec WagonR 1.0 is available with quite a few additional features over the base-spec Ignis and costs Rs 8,000 more. With all basic safety features included and some extra features on offer, the WagonR 1.0 is the clear winner here. However, it misses out on ISOFIX child seat anchor points. If you have kids who require child seats in the car, the Ignis should be your pick. In all other instances, the WagonR is the better package.

WagonR 1.2 ZXi vs Ignis 1.2 Delta

 

WagonR 1.2 ZXi

Ignis 1.2 Delta

Price Difference

Manual

Rs 5.22 lakh

Rs 5.28 lakh

Rs 6,000 (Ignis is more expensive)

AMT

Rs 5.69 lakh

Rs 5.83 lakh

Rs 14,000 (Ignis is more expensive)

Common features (over previous variants): Audio system with Bluetooth/USB/Aux connectivity, Steering-mounted audio controls, 2 speakers, remote keyless entry,electrically adjustable ORVM, front and rear power windows, turn signal on ORVM, rear seat 60:40 split, Day/Night IRVM

What WagonR 1.2 ZXi has over Ignis 1.2 Delta: Rear parking sensors, passenger seatbelt reminder, rear defogger, 7-inch SmartPlay infotainment system with touchscreen, steering-mounted voice controls, front fog lamps, electrically foldable ORVMs, rear wiper and washer

What Ignis 1.2 Delta has over WagonR 1.2 ZXi: Rear seat adjustable head restraints, ISOFIX anchors points

Verdict: The WagonR is clearly the better equipped car here and in this variant, it’s also available with the same powertrain as the Ignis. Clearly, it’s the hatchback of choice here, but not for everyone. If you have a kid who’ll need a child seat, we recommend you go for the Ignis as the WagonR doesn’t get ISOFIX child seat attachment even in this variant. The Ignis also gets adjustable rear headrests, which the WagonR doesn’t - useful for those who spend more time at the back or travel with their families.

Why buy the Maruti Suzuki WagonR?

Boot space: The WagonR, despite being shorter in length compared to the Ignis, boasts more than 80 litres of boot space over the Nexa offering. And that should come in really handy over longer journeys when you have a lot of luggage.

Affordable: Prices of the WagonR start from Rs 4.19 lakh (ex-showroom), and now that it packs all the basic safety features, those who’re tight on budget can go for it too. The entry-level variant is, however, powered by a 1.0-litre engine, which is less powerful, but more fuel efficient than the 1.2-litre unit.

Why buy the Maruti Suzuki Ignis?

Nexa experience: The Ignis is retailed through Nexa showrooms and if you go for one, expect a premium experience over regular Maruti Suzuki showrooms. Even Suzuki’s telematics system, Suzuki Connect, which helps in various functions like tracking your car, driving behaviour analysis and a lot more is only available for Nexa cars.

Design: The Ignis’ styling is subjective - some may like it, some may not. It is quirky, but striking too. And out on the road, it’s sure to turn more heads than the WagonR. So, if you’re looking for a hatchback that stands out, Ignis is the one to pick.

Maruti Suzuki WagonR Variant

Price

Maruti Suzuki Ignis Variant

Price

WagonR 1.0 LXi

Rs 4.19 lakh

   

WagonR 1.0 LXi Opt.

Rs 4.25 lakh

   

WagonR 1.0 VXi

Rs 4.69 lakh

Ignis 1.2 Sigma

Rs 4.67 lakh

WagonR 1.0 VXi Opt.

Rs 4.75 lakh

   

WagonR 1.2 VXi

Rs 4.89 lakh

   

WagonR 1.2 VXi Opt.

Rs 4.96 lakh

   

WagonR 1.0 VXi AMT

Rs 5.16 lakh

   

WagonR 1.2 ZXi

Rs 5.22 lakh

Ignis 1.2 Delta

Rs 5.28 lakh

WagonR 1.0 VXi AMT Opt.

Rs 5.22 lakh

   

WagonR 1.2 VXi AMT

Rs 5.36 lakh

   

WagonR 1.2 VXi AMT Opt.

Rs 5.43 lakh

   

WagonR 1.2 ZXi AMT

Rs 5.69 lakh

Ignis 1.2 AMT Delta

Rs 5.83 lakh

   

Ignis 1.2 Zeta

Rs 5.70 lakh

   

Ignis 1.2 AMT Zeta

Rs 6.26 lakh

   

Ignis 1.2 Alpha

Rs Rs 6.51 lakh

   

Ignis 1.2 AMT Alpha

Rs 7.05 lakh

All prices are (ex-showroom New Delhi)

Disclaimer: This article has not been edited by Deccan Chronicle and is taken from a syndicated feed. Photos: CarDekho.

...




ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT