Trump’s Turn-Citizen-Or-Leave Plan Worries NRIs

Hyderabad: A rumour circulating on social media claims that US President Donald Trump is considering an executive order to revoke green cards of immigrants who do not accept US citizenship within a certain number of years. However, there has been no official confirmation of such a proposal, and immigration experts said the claim should be treated with caution.

The speculation has caused concern among Indian Green Card holders in the United States, many of whom prefer to remain permanent residents rather than pursue citizenship. While US citizenship offers benefits such as voting rights and a US passport, a Green Card already allows individuals to live and work in the country permanently.

One of the key reasons Indians do not convert to US citizenship is that India does not allow full dual citizenship. Giving up Indian citizenship is a major step, as it involves surrendering an Indian passport and moving to an Overseas Citizen of India (OCI) status, which comes with certain restrictions.

Practical concerns also play a role in Indians not opting for US citizenship. The process of applying for US citizenship involves heavy paperwork, fees, and time. Some Green Card holders see little urgency in going through this process when their current status already meets most of their needs.

Dinesh Makkula, a consultancy manager in Hyderabad, said: “One of the most important factors is flexibility. A green card allows individuals to live in the United States while still maintaining strong ties to India. Many travel frequently between the two countries for family, work, health or property-related matters. Retaining Indian citizenship makes such movement and long-term planning easier.”

Legal and immigration experts have pointed out that the rumoured executive order, even if proposed, may face serious challenges. Under existing US law, permanent residents are not required or obligated to become citizens. “A green card is granted with the expectation of lawful residence, not mandatory naturalisation. Revoking it solely based on not applying for citizenship could conflict with established immigration rules and likely face court scrutiny”, Makkula said.