SC Notice on Plea Against Protests at Ramlila Maidan
The traders alleged that frequent protests at the venue adversely affected their fundamental right to conduct business.
NEW DELHI: The Supreme Court on Wednesday sought responses from the Congress, Cockroach Janta Party, All India Students Association (AISA) and Aam Aadmi Party on an amended plea by traders' bodies seeking to denotify Ramlila Maidan as a designated protest site.
The traders alleged that frequent protests at the venue adversely affected their fundamental right to conduct business.
The court also issued notices to the Centre, Delhi government and city police commissioner on the petition filed by the Delhi Kirana Committee and the Delhi Iron and Hardware Merchant Association.
A bench comprising Chief Justice of India Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V. Mohana had, on November 3, asked the traders' bodies to make the protesting organisations parties to the petition.
On Wednesday, the court took the amended petition on record after hearing senior advocate Mukul Rohatgi, appearing for the traders.
"The amended writ petition taken on record. Let notices be issued to the newly-added respondents. The first category concerns the right of protesters to protest. Rohatgi's matter concerns the rights of others, their competing fundamental rights. Both will have to be taken together," the court said.
The bench observed that the competing fundamental rights to protest and conduct business must be balanced.
The CJI said hearing dates would be notified for separate categories of cases relating to recent protests in Delhi and elsewhere.
Among the matters is a plea filed by Rajya Sabha MP and CPM leader M.A. Baby asserting the right to protest, listed for November 27.
Rohatgi argued that prolonged protests disrupted commercial activities in wholesale markets surrounding Ramlila Maidan, particularly during the festival season.
He submitted that businesses had suffered losses running into thousands of crores and opposed the continued designation of Ramlila Maidan as a protest venue.
Solicitor General Tushar Mehta, appearing for the Centre, supported hearing the traders' plea along with the main batch of petitions concerning the right to protest.
The CJI observed that protesters could not occupy a designated venue indefinitely, depriving others of their right to protest and affecting livelihoods.
"You can't occupy a protest site for all times to come. There are other protesters. Where will farmers, journalists, lawyers, etc., go? Where will the trade unions go? Where will the homeless go? Everyone has the right to protest. Designated time must be given for a designated period," the CJI said.
"We are not talking about trade merely in terms of commercial establishments. We are talking about the source of livelihood of a daily-wage worker. Where does that person go for his daily bread?" CJI Kant observed.
The court is hearing several petitions concerning recent protests, including allegations of mass detentions, police brutality, closure of Metro stations and Internet shutdowns.