“Tankiwala asked that the I-T department issue a notice to him as well. When I received no response from the department, I approached the MCOCA court again,” Jain said.— DC Image

Mumbai: Twenty-five years after auctioning a property allegedly linked to fugitive gangster Dawood Ibrahim, the Income Tax (I-T) Department has sought to distance itself from the transaction. In an affidavit filed before a special Maharashtra Control of Organised Crime Act (MCOCA) court, the department has urged the court to impose a fine on Firozabad-based businessman Hemant Jain, who bought the premises in September 2001 but has yet to secure possession, for allegedly misusing the legal process.

Appalled by the department’s response to his plea, Jain alleged that tax officials remained under pressure from the fugitive underworld don.

Jain had purchased a 144-square-foot shop on Jayraj Bhai Street in Nagpada at an I-T department auction on September 20, 2001. However, securing physical possession of the property has proved impossible for over two decades. After exhausting other avenues, Jain approached the MCOCA court, where the D N Nagar police have initiated proceedings to attach the same property.

In its reply to Jain’s application, the I-T department contended that its tax recovery proceedings and subsequent auction sales operate independently of criminal matters handled under the MCOCA.

According to the affidavit filed by Special Public Prosecutor Shabnam Latiwala on behalf of the Tax Recovery Officer, the department had issued recovery notices to the “original owner” for outstanding tax dues. Following the failure to clear the dues, an ITCP-1 certificate was issued, and the property was legally auctioned. “Simultaneously, other statutory agencies declared the original property owner a fugitive under penal law and attached the properties,” the affidavit stated.

Emphasising that statutory revenue dues take precedence over other claims, the department noted that its attachment and auction proceedings began long before the MCOCA offence was registered and were carried out under the Income Tax Act, 1961.

Urging the Special Court to dismiss Jain’s plea with exemplary costs, the department stated: “The applicant (purchaser) is trying to improperly merge an independent tax auction purchase into an unrelated MCOCA criminal proceeding, and the applicant is not even a party to the primary case.” It further accused Jain of attempting to evade stamp duty payments by approaching the MCOCA court, arguing that physical possession was a civil matter that should be pursued before an appropriate civil court.

Jain, however, dismissed the affidavit as a collection of false claims.

“I paid the first instalment of Rs 1 lakh on the day of the auction and the second instalment of the same amount on September 28, 2001. On that very day, the then Public Relations Officer of the I-T department in Mumbai advised me to approach the MCOCA court for possession, as the D N Nagar police had moved to attach the property,” Jain said. “Accordingly, I filed an affidavit in court and served copies to both the police and the I-T department.”

Refuting the charge of stamp duty evasion, Jain stated that he had paid over Rs 1.50 lakh in stamp duty and penalties on December 19, 2004, to get the shop registered in his name.

“The I-T department had initially claimed stamp duty was not applicable to auctioned properties, but the Registrar’s Office in Mumbai refused to register it without payment. Ultimately, I had to pay both the duty and the penalty,” he explained.

Jain added that when he visited the shop after its registration, he met a man named Shabbir Tankiwala, who claimed ownership and insisted that Dawood Ibrahim had no connection to the premises.

“Tankiwala asked that the I-T department issue a notice to him as well. When I received no response from the department, I approached the MCOCA court again,” Jain said.

Criticising the department’s latest filing, Jain added: “The reply neither mentions Dawood Ibrahim’s name nor provides a description of the property. They have made false claims, which shows officials are still scared of Dawood Ibrahim.”

Tags: