Delhi Police Tells SC Women Officers Not Mandatory for Crowd Control
The police also responded to the Supreme Court's October 11 order, which asked it not to “hinder” journalists, lawyers and other professionals from doing their work.
By : DC Correspondent
Update: 2026-11-18 13:09 GMT
The Delhi Police has told the Supreme Court that there is no strict rule saying that only women police officers can "handle" women during crowd-control operations. This was said in response to petitions claiming that women protesters and journalists were manhandled during protests demanding the resignation of Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) Gyanesh Kumar.
The petitions were filed by the Network of Women in Media, India, through advocate Aarthi Rajan. The Delhi Union of Journalists, Free Speech Collective and Kerala Union of Working Journalists were also part of the petitions.
In its reply to the court, the police said that the requirement of women officers during searches and arrests involving women was different from the rules followed during crowd-control operations.
"With regards to the allegations of manhandling of women journalists, it is respectfully submitted that the requirement of women personnel handling women is not a statutory mandate in the context of crowd-control operations, in the same manner as it is expressly prescribed under the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita 2023 in relation to searches and arrests," the police said, an english daily reported.
The police also explained that officers are deployed by keeping in mind propriety, avoiding unnecessary confrontation and controlling tensions, particularly when women are present. It said male officers being present at the Cockroach Janata Party (CJP) protest was not misconduct. Male officers may also help women officers or act as first responders, it added.
The affidavit stated that, "Such decisions have to be taken at the fraction of a second."
The police also responded to the Supreme Court's October 11 order, which asked it not to "hinder" journalists, lawyers and other professionals from doing their work.
It said the order did not apply to reel-makers, social media influencers or people who did not follow lawful instructions at a prohibited assembly.
While saying that it "fully respects the role of the press," the police alleged that some people carrying cameras and microphones at the protest site claimed to be journalists.
As per the police, these people were allowed to work unless they created problems for public order and law. It also said that existing laws do not recognise content creators as "working journalists."
The police further raised questions about whether "reel-makers can be elevated to the status of journalists or reporters." It said the absence of a clear legal difference between journalists and content creators made it difficult to manage the crowd during the July march towards Parliament. The police described the march as an "Unauthorised" protest in which thousands of people took part.
The police also claimed that its personnel had acted with restraint during the operation. It said people who were detained by mistake due to mistaken identity were released after their identities were checked.
Delhi Police further stated that, "The police action was directed solely towards dispersing and removing the protestors from the illegal protest sites and restoring public order, and was neither intended nor directed towards detaining, restraining or obstructing any media personnel in the lawful discharge of their professional duties".