Manchester: With lingering disappointment of an unfavourable verdict in the James Anderson fracas, India go into the fourth cricket Test against England on Thursday facing a selection dilemma over leaving out a couple of out-of-form players.
With their backs to the wall after a ‘double blow’ last week when they were thrashed by 266 runs in the third Test followed by ICC appointed Judicial Commissioner’s verdict declaring Anderson ‘not guilty’, it will be redemption time for Mahendra Singh Dhoni and his boys as they hope to get their acts together at the Old Trafford.
The team management might look at a couple of changes in the side with chances of veteran opener Gautam Gambhir and off-spinner R. Ashwin making it to the team as Shikhar Dhawan’s poor form and Rohit Sharma’s atrocious shot selection might bring down the axe on the duo.
Although the series is levelled 1-1, poor on-field performance and losing a battle off the field have left the team in a vulnerable state.
It would be helpful if they also draw some inspiration from the 2007-08 tour to Australia. It was the last time an Indian cricketer was involved in a fracas that involved ‘Level 3 offence’.
Dhoni will like to emulate erstwhile captain Anil Kumble, who had led from the front, not only making a dignified off-field stand but also marshalling his troops well on-field, leading the side to a memorable 72-run win at Perth.
In supporting Jadeja, even refusing to be placated by efforts of both the BCCI and the ECB, Dhoni has done the necessary bit off-the-field. Now he needs to get it right inside the boundary ropes, for that is what the series is all about.
Seven years down the line, everyone does recall the Andrew Symonds-Harbhajan Singh controversy, but the score line nevertheless read that Australia beat India 2-1. A similar defeat here will make the worst possible reading for Dhoni’s overseas Test report card that is already quite overloaded with embarrassing losses since 2011.
The answer to his troubles can also be found in the 2007-08 series. At Trent Bridge and Lord’s, India had deployed five bowlers — a strategy last deployed overseas at Adelaide in that same series.
With a draw and a win at Trent Bridge and Lord’s respectively, it can be argued that this ploy was worked wonders for India. The argument holds water because on a flat track at Southampton, their seven front-line batsmen could only manage 330 and 178 in two innings.
With the series crucially poised, it begs for a strategic rethink. Rohit Sharma’s inconsistency has led the team down at crucial junctures.
But it can be argued that a fifth bowler there might have made a huge difference, especially if he was a spinner. The case for Ashwin to play his first Test of the series couldn’t be stronger. India are looking for an extra-batsman and he has two Test hundreds to his name. Ashwin has also stood at first slip for India until he was dropped mid-way through the Test series in South Africa.
This catching bit is important because the third Test was lost more due to dropped catches than insipid batting and undisciplined bowling. Also, because Shikhar Dhawan handles first-slip duties currently, and he hasn’t performed his primary duty — score runs.
