72nd Day Of Lockdown

Maharashtra74860323292587 Tamil Nadu2587214316208 Delhi236459542615 Gujarat18117122121122 Rajasthan96526744209 Uttar Pradesh88705257230 Madhya Pradesh82835003358 West Bengal61682410364 Karnataka4063151453 Andhra Pradesh3971246468 Bihar3945174123 Telangana3020155699 Jammu and Kashmir260194631 Odisha238814169 Haryana2356105521 Punjab2301200044 Kerala149565112 Assam14862854 Uttarakhand9592225 Jharkhand6612965 Chhatisgarh5481211 Tripura4231730 Himachal Pradesh3401186 Chandigarh2972144 Puducherry88300 Manipur83110 Goa73500 Nagaland5800 Arunachal Pradesh3710 Meghalaya33131 Mizoram1410 Sikkim200

Bihar minister blames smartphones for rapes

Published Jul 15, 2014, 10:57 am IST
Updated Mar 31, 2019, 7:13 pm IST
Bihari, a first-time minister said he did not mean girls were responsible for rapes
Bihar minister for arts, culture and youth affairs, Binay Bihari
 Bihar minister for arts, culture and youth affairs, Binay Bihari

Patna: Bihar’s minister for arts, culture and youth affairs, Binay Bihari, on Monday sparked a minor furore in the Assembly with his statement linking the rise in the number of incidents of rapes with the presence of smartphones with girls.

“Smartphones in the hands of young people, especially girls, has caused more problems than it has solved. Smartphones have led to a rise in the incidents of rape,” said Bihari.


His statement attracted severe protests from women MLAs cutting across party lines while many male MLAs were heard supporting it.

Read: 10 free Android apps that can help to save your life

Bihari, a first-time minister who was inducted into the Jitan Ram Manjhi government in July’s cabinet expansion, however, said he did not mean girls were responsible for the rapes. His statement, however, was apparently viewed by many women MLAs to mean so. Post-lunch proceedings in the Assembly witnessed uproar over Bihari’s comments, prompting a number of women legislators to protest it as wrong-headed analysis of a social problem.

“The process of love has got a boost due to the availability of mobile phones. Rapes have also increased due to mobile phones in the hands of young girls. Sometimes wrong numbers dialled by mistake bring about relationships between boys and girls and pose problems,” said Sarfaraz Alam, the ruling JD(U) MLA from Jokihat, supporting the minister’s statements.

Vikram Kunwar, the BJP legislator from Raghunathpur, said: “This device called mobile phones is the main culprit behind so many incidents of rapes. Such incidents were fewer before mobile phones came. Guardians of young people have been careless in giving them mobile phones and not monitoring them.”

“Boys are 100 per cent responsible for rapes. It is the boys who do such kind of acts with the girls. Impressionable girls who step out of their homes mostly in the villages to towns for education or jobs often get lured by the boys into such acts,” said Neeta Chaudhary, the JD(U) legislator from Tarapur Assembly constituency.

In the past, several SP leaders had made similar disparaging and insensitive comments on women. Mulayam Singh Yadav, the father of UP Chief Minister Akhilesh Yadav and SP supremo also condemnable statements during Lok Sabha polls that rapists should not be hanged. “Boys make mistakes, but they cannot be hanged for that,” he said.

Only on Sunday, UP minister Abhishek Misra had again drawn flak for his party with his ‘insensitive’ remarks on women’s safety.

“We cannot deploy constable behind every woman in the state because this is practically impossible,” he said on Saturday.