Washington: For the first time, a federal judge has suppressed evidence obtained without a warrant by US law enforcement using a stingray, a surveillance device that can trick suspects' cell phones into revealing their locations.
US District Judge William Pauley in Manhattan on Tuesday ruled that defendant Raymond Lambis' rights were violated when the US Drug Enforcement Administration used such a device without a warrant to find his Bronx apartment.
The DEA had used a stingray to identify Lambis' apartment as the most likely location of a cell phone identified during a drug-trafficking probe. Pauley said doing so constituted an unreasonable search. "Absent a search warrant, the government may not turn a citizen's cell phone into a tracking device," Pauley wrote.
The ruling marked the first time a federal judge had suppressed evidence obtained using a stingray, according to the American Civil Liberties Union, which like privacy advocacy groups has criticized law enforcement's use of such devices. "This opinion strongly reinforces the strength of our constitutional privacy rights in the digital age," ACLU attorney Nathan Freed Wessler said in a statement. It was unclear whether prosecutors would seek to appeal. A spokeswoman for Manhattan US Attorney Preet Bharara, whose office was prosecuting the case, declined to comment.
Stingrays, also known as "cell site simulators," mimic cell phone towers in order to force cell phones in the area to transmit "pings" back to the devices, enabling law enforcement to track a suspect's phone and pinpoint its location. Critics of the technology call it invasive and say it has been regularly used in secret to catch suspect in violation of their rights under the US Constitution.
The ACLU has counted 66 agencies in 24 states and the District of Columbia that own stingrays but says that number is unrepresentative in light of what it calls secrecy surrounding purchases of the devices. A Maryland appeals court in March became what the ACLU said was the first state appellate court to order evidence obtained using a stingray suppressed. Pauley's decision was the first at the federal level. The US Justice Department in September changed its internal policies and required government agents to obtain a warrant before using a cell site simulator.
Bernard Seidler, Lambis' lawyer, noted that occurred a week after his client was charged. He said it was unclear if the drug case against Lambis would now be dismissed.
