• icon
  • icon
  • icon
  • icon

Yet another IIT suicide

Anxious parents do a balancing act between expectations and fear of losing their child to academic pressure
Anxious parents do a balancing act between expectations and fear of losing their child to academic pressure

On Wednesday afternoon, Nitin Kumar Reddy, a final year mechanical engineering student from IIT, Madras committed suicide.

Nitin left a Facebook message on the wall that read: “I fought hard but lost.”

There is more to that final post than what meets the eye. It is not just Nitin.

In the past five months three students from the same institution (including V. Anoop from the same department) have ended their life. Faculty members and officials say that such incidents cannot be attributed to academic pressure alone, but call for immediate attention.

“This is a complex issue that needs to be addressed. No one can say it’s because of academic pressure. There could be several reasons,” says M. Govardhan, dean (students) at IIT-M.

Academicians and educationists feel that students are aware of the pressure they have to handle while they are at such an institution.

“It is a known fact that studying at IIT is no easy task. The students who are part of that institution are self-motivated and are aware of the academic expectations. Moreover, every student may be facing personal and cultural problems as well. The education system cannot be blamed,” says E. Balaguruswamy, former vice-chancellor of Anna University.

Nitin’s department-mates, appeared sad yet strangely indifferent. Maybe because of their exams. They say it’s all about the survival of the fittest.

“It’s exam time and all of us are trying to perform well. We come here to clear the course and such incidents are unfortunate. While some students work with a clear-cut timetable, some may lose their confidence mid-way,” says a second year mechanical engineering student on condition of anonymity.

“I have never felt the pressure of studying at IIT. But it is the survival of the fittest. Entering this prestigious institution is a task on its own. But students have to be responsible and not lose hope,” says a first year M-Tech student.

Nitin’s life changed course when he approached the head of the department to learn that his course needed to be extended by six months. About this incident, the HOD said that the department was still in shock.

“We are all very upset because of this incident. If we lose a student, it’s traumatic but nothing can be done about it,” says S.P. Venkateshan, HoD. of mechanical department, who informed Nitin that he wouldn’t be graduating in May along with his batch mates. “He visited my office twice and that’s when I interacted with him,” says Venkateshan.

Counselling could to an extent help students manage the stress and pressure. Asked if the system is in place at IIT-M, Govardhan says: “We have recently appointed a qualified, fulltime counsellor who is extremely helpful. Students are allowed to approach the department with their problems. Once in a while, the dean of HoDs also interacts with the students so as to make sure they’re comfortable.”

Reasons may be many and yet to be identified, but the frequency at which students commit suicide is alarming and worth an investigation.

Your Comment
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
refresh
karrar hussain 14/07/2011 - 02:00pm

1. When students qualify in a professional entrance examination, it is considered by their loved ones as job in that realm which is a negative force on students. 2. Most suicides are among males and on getting admitted to promising institutes; 3. Only God can help in such cases.

Nitin Gupta(Rivaldo) 10/05/2011 - 12:27am

Everytime a pedestrian is run over by a car, it is not always the driver's fault.
IIT-B student has short attendance in 3 courses.. CGP: 4ish out of 10. He commits suicide. Profs and system are blamed.
IIT Kanpur post-grad student can’t get a job in campus placements. He commits suicide.
Recently an IIT-M student gets BTP extension. Spirals into depression. commits suicide. Prof. is under scanner.
Let’s ask a few questions before we begin to get Sentimental about yet another suicide.
Should Ganguly have committed suicide when he was given an Indefinite extension after being dropped in 92? Would you have blamed the BCCI for crushing the ambitions of a 22-year-old?
But Ganguly didn’t commit suicide. He waited!
So, How is someone's act of Impulse the system’s fault ?
Moving On...
In 2005, one of the very early cases of student suicides an IIT Bombay student Vijay Nakula committed suicide, for getting XX grade (which means you would have to repeat the course because of attendance shortage) in three courses among other reasons.
Tomorrow let’s say a professor commits suicide for lack of attendance of students in his class. Let’s say, he got depressed for that reason.. Let’s say, he is giving his best, still no one is attending the class. Would you blame the student fraternity in the colleges for not being serious about studies? Would you be willing to blame the system (markets in this case) ?
Would the student fraternity be willing to go for all the ;ectures to prevent any more Profs from going into depression and any subsequent suicides? Take your guess.
My guess is no. My Guess is an emphatic, no!!
Professor writes a mail mentioning the list of people to be awarded fail grade. Student commits suicide after finding his name in it.
Argument. The e-mail was harsh!!
If tomorrow a Critic trashes a movie, can the lead actor commit suicide citing a harsh review in his defence?. Would you buy that ?
Why are we glorifying suicides in IITs? Why are we projecting them as 'victims of the system'?
Somebody who takes his own life for a BTP extension, I am sorry to say, is a victim of his own choices ! (Whatever may have been the circumstances.)
So let’s stop projecting these students as martyrs. For it creates a false precedent. A sort of suicidal peer pressure (Pardon the Phrase, but true) among the students to come.
I call it the Induction effect of committing suicides.
People blame academic pressure for these suicides. Oh It’s too stressful. I ask, why should IIT be easy?
You feel you can take it, fine. Else 1uit.
Everyone is fine with the goods which IIT tag has to offer The campus placements for majority, and the other fringe benefits of being an IITan. Default respect in Society among other things.
So why shouldn't you be made to earn every cent of it ?
You find the pressure enormous, Quit IIT!! Do something else. Why quit your life?
If you choose to stay in IIT, Play by the rules.
The world doesn't owe you a living! It was here first.
An IIT-K student doesn’t get a campus placement. He commits suicide. The argument given to his friend before ending his life was, “Itni mehnat kari, Itne number laaye.. phir bhi job nahin lagi! ”
Can a hockey player commit suicide for the same reason? “Yaar itni mehnat kari, itne goal kiye, phir bhi advertisement nahin mile!” Job nahin mili, suicide kar li?
What bothers me is the mindset of some of the students that IIT somehow owes them a living! No it doesn’t. Nor does the world!!
You didn’t create that brand. Your predecessors did. So how does IIT owe you anything?
IIT is an educational institute. Not a life insurance!
So-called friends!
The friends of the person who committed suicide are the first to criticise the system. I say, If you were such a good friend, why didn’t you make sure he attended the lectures, when his attendance was getting short? Why didn’t you drag him to classes ?
If he hates the classes, why didn’t you help him find what he loved doing?
He got extension because his project got delayed, Why didn’t you make his project report. If you think the system pressure can often lead to suicide.. Didn’t you see your friend’s suicide coming when he was failing in courses and missing deadlines?
In one sentence you blame the system and the pressure, when you did nothing to help your friend though it ?
And the worst part is, none of the friends had an inkling of what was about to come!
So much for being a Friend.

Which system is at fault?
If you choose to highlight these 3 Suicides, I can show you 20 people in the same batch who have done exceedingly well. Some may be under the same Prof, who is under the scanner.
Three out of 5,000. In science that’s not called a system error. That’s called standard deviation.
Darwin would have dismissed the same, with his “survival of the fittest” argument.
You could call me cold, or apathetic, or ignorant or anything you want to, but if you are really serious about ending these suicides.
My humble request is stop glorifying every suicide.
For every time a pedestrian gets run over, it’s not always the cars fault. Assuming that's it's always a drivers fault is a matter of convenience. Not fact!
May be it was error of judgment on the student’s part.
Human solutions.
People have suggested all sort of Solutions.
Ban the LAN. ( Internet). Reduce work load/ academic stress
Counseling Sessions.
Now that we have failed with the logical solutions. Let's try a human solution!
Suicide is an impulse decision...
So, I don’t think we need to subtract or reduce anything. We need to add something to the system.

Sumit Bhattacharya 04/05/2012 - 10:24am

You r right, but it should not be blamed on the student as well, have you heard about emotional disorder, please read about borderline personality disorder which affects a man or woman when they are arround 18 , 70 to 80 % of peple suffering from the same try to commit suicide, http://bpdayurveda.blogspot.in/2011/12/what-is-borderline-personality-di...

meena 10/05/2011 - 12:15am

Academic institutions should have couselling as well as mental health advisors. It is really unfortunate that there is such indifference among staff and peer group in such a prestigious institution. I feel the problem lies in the system and sometimes people seeking help are looked down upon. This will only cause more damage to the students. IIT or no IIT life has to go on.
We have had similar incidents in the US where a student (also a victim of bullying) due to sheer mental pressure brought a gun and shot several people including himself.
Most institutions brag about how rigorous the programme is, they need to shift gears and look at how to develop a person over all as a competent individual.

Shekar 09/05/2011 - 06:52am

Only the top notch students after handling enormous pressure get in to IIT's. The professor cannot brush off the allegations saying that it's unfortunate. it is because of their sadistic attitude that students are losing their life.
The professor must be punished, it is the duty of the institution and the professor not only to maintain a good course curriculum but also make sure students are not under too much pressure and have the right to complain against such sadistic professors.
This reminds of the movie 3 Idiots, we have to acknowledge the fact that such professors exist in every college,university and IIT. It's imperative that they be punished for their sadistic acts against the students
Students of IITs who are the best brains in the country should raise their voice. I cant stop laughing at one of the students' comment about survival of the fittest. That has already been tested when they write the entrance exams.... at least sympathise with our fellow students.

saravana 10/05/2011 - 06:07pm

Who is the professor? As far as I know the student was neither failed or expelled, only given a six-month extension, which is pretty mild. The system in IIT Madras is so mild that practically no student is failed or expelled. To commit suicide because "he could not graduate together with his friends" and because he feared losing "his software job" was very stupid and immature. I pity this student. In any of these suicide cases parents are equally to be blamed. The parents don't keep in touch with students and encourage them in studies. Many of the IIT students only show interest in studies before they get the campus placement offer to that big-bucks MNC company. After the placement offer, class attendance and final year project work etc are a big joke.